Is Pakistan Heading for Civil War?

History has numerous records of civil wars, and the profound subjectivity of each war gives us good reason to think they cannot be grouped under a single empirical umbrella. With the respective contexts of their conditions in view, they defy being seen through one specific prism.

Nevertheless, a civil war could be defined as a war having the trait of “insurgency” occurring amid conflicting factors born from within a state. Most commonly, civil wars happen between state powers and citizen groups of a country. Civil wars have also been fought between two or more ethnic-nations inside a country. A civil war passes different phases of development and the weapons warring groups use are conventional ones, but there have been cases where home-made weapons like explosives were used to kill the opponent.

The history of civil wars is a long one, and can reasonably be traced to when the term “civilian” came into use. But older wars that were like these later wars have been around for as long as humans themselves. Some eminent civil wars are:
The American Civil War (where USA’s northern states represented by Washington stood on one side and 11 southern seceding states termed the “Confederacy” stood on the other).
In olden times there was the Roman civil war between 100 BC and 400 AD. Anarchy in the Byzantine Empire. The French wars of religion. The Marian Civil War. The thirty years of war between Protestants and Catholics in the Holy Roman Empire from 1618 to 1648. The Irish Confederate Wars. The English Civil War ( 1st, 2nd & 3rd). The French and American revolutions. The South American wars of independence. The Argentine civil wars. The Greek civil war. The Uruguayan civil war. The Thousand Days’ War. The Mexican revolution. The Finish civil war. The Chinese civil war. The Austrian Civil War. The Spanish Civil War and the Vietnam War in the 20th century, which were one of the bloodiest ever. The Colombian Conflict. The Bangladeshi Liberation War. The Lebanese civil war, Angolan civil war, Afghan civil war, Sri Lankan civil war, Tajikistani civil war, Yemeni civil war, the Iraqi-Kurdish civil war, Nepalese civil war, Congolese civil war and the civil war in Iraq after the dismantling of the Baath party are among the many examples a civil war.

A student shout slogans as he marches with others during a protest rally against an anti-Islam film made in the U.S. which they say mocks the Prophet Mohammad, in Gilgit
When I look at the situation in my country, I feel a kind of helplessness to analyze what is actually happening. Should I think we’re closing in on conditions to shape a civil war among us? Or should I say what we’re caught in is conflicts that won’t really push us into a civil war? It is common knowledge that writers, doctors, lawyers, theologians, teachers and bankers of a certain Muslim sect have been targeted with the violence continuing. Although others too have been rung up, it’s no secret that the major brunt is the lot of the Shiites.
Besides sectarian tensions, there are insurgencies growing in Baluchistan, KPK province and the FATA. We can hear of a movement that proclaims a “free Baluchistan”, there is a nationalist movement in Gilgit and Baltistan regions and one may sniff a separatist temperament in areas of Sindh. Whereas the government is failing day by day to tackle issues like street crimes, bank robberies and corruption on different tiers.

At this very moment while I’m writing, 3 men have been shot dead. Yesterday a Scout Group Leader named Arshad Hussain Naqvi, belonging to the Karachi Open District (which is affiliated with the Sind Boy-Scout Association, the Pakistan Boy-Scout Association and the World Scouts’ Bureau), was assassinated. He was someone who never stepped back from his voluntary sense of duty and never turned his back on one in need. He was there in Kashmir when the earthquake hit and recently in areas of Sindh where floods turned everything upside down. He went all the way to Thar and Mitthi to help all he could in the rescue efforts there. A life lived in sacrifice, and one bullet to hush it up.

Recent news tells me two people were shot near Naagan chowrungi, top-notch journalist Hamid Mir sustained multiple shot wounds, and someone called Saleem Haider, leading the Muhajir Ittehad Tehreek, was targeted near Jauhar Chowrungi. The list of people being killed could go on and on but I must think of bringing my words to an end.
One incident that stopped me in my tracks was the killing of a primary level student who was rehearsing to play a brother in a tableau. No one knows who is responsible and his family is protesting against the government for their loss. I have been thinking of those other tableau-participants and what they must be discussing at an age when their discussions should be about such innocent aspects as their primary school-age guarantees. Instead of talking about things one talks about in childhood, they’re talking about death and terror.
Everyone these days expects opinions on a solution if you point to what’s wrong. I don’t think I have a suitable opinion or advice to offer. I just want to say that those running the institutions in our society must find a way out of the present mess. It isn’t a consolation that what we’re caught in won’t really push us into a civil war. If matters are not taken seriously, the conflict which we’re resting on today will break dam tomorrow. And then we will have a real treat at our hands, for that will be a civil war.


(This Article was Shaped and Structured by Tabisch Aliem)

Syed Muhammad Mujtaba

Syed Muhammad Mujtaba

Mujtaba is studying International Relations at University of Karachi. He likes to volunteer for social causes. He is also a spokesperson for a number of awareness-related platforms.
Syed Muhammad Mujtaba



You may also like...

11 Responses

  1. ummara says:

    May Allah bless our country….

    • S. M. Mujtaba says:

      yeah.. but i think first step should be from our side because Allah promises to help us not to take initiatives. This is our duty to think to change our society.

  2. ummara says:

    ……. this is what happening

  3. Rimsha says:

    Amazingly, amazingly well-written…the current situation of our country is one that is ripe for a civil war..but the question remains..will the nation be able to stand united at the face of such conditions? The success of any civil war rests on its elements being united in their struggle, whereas here, we have people fighting for different causes…Nevertheless, i hope things change for the better without further shedding of blood, Ameen.
    Looking forward to more articles from you :) Bravo! and all the best :)

    • S. M. Mujtaba says:

      Thank you..
      It become a big problem of us that everyone has its own definition and meaning of nation. moreover there is no consensus on nation and the rights of nation. Everyone wants a bigger piece of cake. No one is ready to share but all of these are artificially originates for the sake of some interests by some unknown person ( :p ) as i understand..
      Thank You ones again.. :-) it is highly appreciated to me.

  4. sharjeel says:

    Actually, ‘civil unrest’ will be a more appropriate term here. As ‘civil war’ is a term that suits the scenario where a government is targeted by a political faction. Here, what we are seeing is type of an unrest and not in all parts of Pakistan but in some specific parts to create hindrance.

    • S. M. Mujtaba says:

      Actually my point is that there is no specific and particular definition of civil war and you are right we are not in civil war at this time but the point which i raised in article is that we are on the verge of civil war.
      And in the last, lot of thanks for your concern :-)

  5. Tayba Khalid says:

    Good effort

  6. Wardah Nasir says:

    Courageous effort! i must say,
    written at his best!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>